Red, Blue, or Purple? Choosing the Right Cybersecurity Assessment for Your Organization

---

Every testing method has its own benefits and outcomes at the end. Security testing isn’t one-size-fits-all. The “right” assessment depends on your goals, which include proving real-world exposure, hardening defences, or accelerating collaboration between offence and defence. Here’s a straightforward, fact-based approach that explains what each approach provides and how it matches your company’s requirements.

This guide will also help you decide between red, blue, and purple team assessments that you can share with stakeholders.

Let’s begin by understanding what each assessment defines.

Breaking the Apprehension About Each Assessment

The Red Team (Adversary Emulation):

A sanctioned team emulates real attackers to test how well your organisation can prevent, detect, and respond to stealthy, objective-driven campaigns. The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) defines a red team as an authorised group that mimics an adversary to assess enterprise security and show what works for defenders.

The Blue Team (Defensive Assessment):

Blue teams are responsible for operational vulnerability evaluations, tune detections, and improving response playbooks, often during or after offensive exercises. The NIST glossary frames the blue team as the group that identifies risks in the operating environment and provides mitigations.

Purple Team (Collaborative Validation):

Purple teaming isn’t a “third team” so much as a collaborative approach that brings red and blue together to test controls in a structured, iterative loop: attack, detect, and refine. It aligns well with MITRE ATT&CK, a globally used knowledge base of real-world adversary tactics and techniques that both sides can reference during exercises.

Why Does It Hold a Crucial Significance Now?

According to the Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report for 2024, social engineering and the use of stolen credentials are common in all regions. The most common breach patterns are “System Intrusion,” “Social Engineering,” and “Basic Web Application Attacks.” Teams can verify whether controls identify and stop these tactics in real-world situations rather than just on paper by using ongoing, threat-informed testing.

Picking The Right Assessment for Your Objective:

Let us help you with a simple guide to choosing each team, as well as the factors that influence your decision.

Here’s when to select the Red Team:

• Presents senior leadership with business risk by posing questions like “Can an attacker reach crown-jewel data?”
• Examine end-to-end security across technology, processes, and people (including lateral movement and social engineering).
• Use ATT&CK-mapped TTPs to benchmark resilience against a particular threat actor.

Here’s when you need a Blue Team:

• Logging, detections, alert triage, and incident response runbooks are examples of baseline and uplift defensive operations.
• Close visibility gaps and verify coverage against common tactics (phishing-initiated compromise, credential theft).
• Demonstrate that previous test mitigations are effective and do not regress.

Insights for selecting the Purple Team:

• Co-design the test cases with success criteria by both teams in order to shorten the feedback loop between attack and detection.
• Map each test to MITRE ATT&CK techniques, run it, measure detection quality (fidelity, latency), then tune controls live.
• Create a repeatable program that constantly validates control efficacy, which is very helpful when staff and budgets are limited.

Using A Recognised Framework:

For scoping and running technical tests, NIST SP 800-115 remains a foundational guide to information security testing and assessment (planning, information gathering, vulnerability analysis, exploitation, and post-testing). Even if you pursue purple teaming, use 800-115 to structure engagement rules, data handling, and reporting.

To make tests threat-relevant, align scenarios to MITRE ATT&CK (enterprise, cloud, mobile, ICS). ATT&CK provides a shared language, enabling red teams to emulate and blue teams to detect the same behaviours that form the core of effective purple teaming.

A Quick Decision Checklist:

Work through this checklist to determine quickly whether your organisation requires a Red, Blue, or Purple Team assessment. Each option aligns to a specific security goal, helping you choose the right approach.

• Executive proof of risk? Start with a Red Team to show business impact.
• Detection & response maturity gaps? Run a Blue Team uplift (log sources, rules, playbooks), then re-test.
• Need fast, measurable improvement? Stand up Purple Team sprints: pick ATT&CK techniques, test, tune, retest.
• Compliance & safety guardrails needed. Apply NIST SP 800-115 for planning, scope, and reporting across all three.

Here’s a quick assessment guide for which assessment you require.

Question	If ‘Yes’
Are you unsure if your defenses can detect or stop modern attack techniques?	Blue Team
Do you need to strengthen logging, monitoring, and SOC workflows?	Blue Team
Are you trying to validate detection coverage against MITRE ATT&CK techniques?	Purple Team
Do you want to test end-to-end security across people, process, and technology?	Red Team
Are you preparing for cloud migration, system upgrades, or major architecture changes?	Red Team

Bottom line

While it may seem that a single team can be your solution, it should actually be a layered plan: a blue team for assurance, a red team for validation, and a purple team for maturity detection.

If leadership needs a clear wake-up call about real business risks, choose a Red Team assessment. If your defensive operations need strengthening, whether in logging, detection, or incident response, then select a Blue Team evaluation. And if you want continuous, measurable improvement, go for a Purple Team approach, mapping each exercise to MITRE ATT&CK so that every cycle helps close real detection and response gaps.

Ready to strengthen your security posture? Connect with Ampcus Cyber to choose the right assessment for your organization and build a more resilient defense.

Enjoyed reading this blog? Stay updated with our latest exclusive content by following us on Twitter and LinkedIn.